St.
Vrain Angler News & Muse January 25, 2005
Greetings!
I hope you are
well today, enjoying the warm temps we are
having
- if you live along the front range of Colorado, that is! Mom reports that
NE Ohio continues in the deep freeze, and that Colorado has had higher temps
than much of Florida. Hmm.
Have you noticed
the word on the street now has to do with lots snow and moisture in the
mountains? Great snow pack for this time of year? Folks around the shop are
speaking with optimism about this season's fishing.
And reports keep
coming in about good fishing when folks are going fishing.
Mark, Jay and I
just got back from our monthly shop fishing trip. Sixteen of us went to
11-Mile Canyon for Saturday, Sunday and Monday, and everyone had a fine
time. On Sunday, all of us fished in the Canyon. It was very bright, the
water was very low and cold, yet a few midges were emerging and trout were
feeding on them on the surface. I was able to help a few of our friends with
rigging and fly presentation tips, and for the last hour or so on Monday,
Joe and I had a casting lesson.
Cool.
The water was
very clear, too. While the flow in the canyon has been stable for some time,
I wonder if the cold temps
influence
the clarity of the water as well. The fish were visible in their lies, and
when they were feeding we had the chance to observe their movements to bugs
or our flies. It was pretty neat doings.
Dallas used an
RS2 for most of Sunday, and caught plenty of fish. He was drifting the fly
on or just under the film, hunting fish that were feeding and then feeding
them his fake. It was interesting to see some small mayflies emerging on
Sunday, although I didn't see a single one on Monday. I wonder if the fish
might have been keying on the larger bug that day? Dallas was using about a
size 20 or so.
Kirk had a
concoction of his own that was a cross between a black beauty midge larva
and a choronamid emerger. The white part on the front of the fly was white
CDC tied over the eye of the hook, and the body was black thread with a
bright rib. I think there was some peacock or black dubbing in there
somewhere - I only got one quick glimpse of the fly because Kirk saw a fish
that needed cast to. The fly seemed large, but the fish ate it.
I wondered if it
was a good imitation of an emerging midge,
after
all. Even small midges get twice as big when they emerge as the shuck slides
off the back of the bug's body.
I spent some time
with Karim - and if that is misspelled, I apologize in advance, my new
friend - on Sunday morning. He's a friend of Kirk's and is just
getting into fly fishing. He had some borrowed gear along and a few flies
that he and Kirk had tied in the cabin during evening hours.
We stood in the
stream observing trout, talking about what was going on. I asked if he'd
like to see some bugs and what they were doing and he said he'd like that
very much. We pulled the seine I carry out of my backpack, stuck it in the
water and took a look. There were a few midge shucks, one midge adult and
lots of floating debris in the net.
Then, Karim stood
upstream a bit and disturbed the bottom of the stream while I held the net
below his feet. The first bug that popped into view was a size 4 crane fly
larva, which surprised Karim. There were also some midge larva in several
sizes and colors, although all were thin and segmented. As we stood there, I
noticed an emerging
midge floating by and pointed it out to Karim and Kirk, who had joined us by
that time. We watched the bug float along, and could see the shuck coming
off the back, and eventually noticed when the bug freed itself from the
shuck and started buzzing the surface in preparation for take-off.
Everyone thought
that was pretty neat.
I asked Karim
what he thought about the emerging midge, and he said, "It is vulnerable",
and I told him he was right, and that was when the fish would eat the bug.
We discussed the bugs and how to fish them a little more, and then I asked
him if he would like to see it all in action, to which he replied, "Sure!"
I rigged up with
a long section of 7X tippet and tied on
a
size 24 stuck in the shuck midge emerger. This is a fly that I developed in
the early 80's after a trip to Cheesman Canyon and a talk with my old friend
Tom Waugh. Tom tied a pattern that was a good imitation of emerging midges,
and I made a few adjustments, basically stealing a fine idea from an
experienced angler. That's how flies are developed.
Karim made the
comment that the flies were mimics. That's a good term, not?
I've started
tying a few of the midge adults and stuck in shuck patterns using yellow
CDC. The flies are pretty visible on the water, and I like being able to see
the fly and point it out to folks when we fish together. Sometimes, I use
orange hackle, too, which is very visible on the water.
After tying the
fly on, I dropped it on the water and asked Karim if he could see it. He
said he could, so I made a very short roll cast in the direction we'd be
fishing just to be sure he could still see it, which he could. Ah, young
eyes.
Then, we stood in
one spot watching for a rising fish. This was a day when rising fish were,
well, rising, just not often. At times there were once-in-a-row risers,
which usually don't cause me to cast. I like to see one fish rise several
times in the same spot over a few minutes to be sure that fish is looking
up.
We found such a
fish. It was easy to see it against the light-colored bottom of the
streambed and through the clear water. The trout was fining there, moving
from side to side from time to time and indicating it was munching midge
larva. Once in a while it rose to intercept a morsel on the surface, and
that was enough for us! We were hooked, and hoped the same for the fish.
I explained where
I would put the fly on the water and why, then put the fly there. On the
first drift, the fish took the fly but I missed the set. Quite simply, I was
not ready. Then I remembered that the first cast is the best chance, if the
fly is presented properly. Oh well. Recalling the saying of an old friend -
sometimes trout forget - I waited for a minute or two so the fish
would forget and continued to observe the fish while Karim and I visited. A
few casts later, the fish once again ate the fly.
"That is the
coolest thing I've seen yet," Karim said.
"I agree," I
said. "That's what I love about winter fly fishing
with
midges. I can see the fish, make a cast and watch the fish take the fly."
A few minutes
later Karim caught his own trout on a midge pattern fished on the surface.
That was good, too.
In the meantime,
there were folks fishing the river who were standing where the fish wanted
to be, and using lead and big bobbers in the midst of rising trout. Oh well.
I wish I could help all of them understand.
Fly fishing has,
in my opinion, done some disservice to new anglers by selling them good
gear, then setting them up with a selection of bead head nymphs, lead,
bobbers and basic instructions to cast - really, chuck - the fly out into a
riffle or run and keep the bobber floating along evenly. They are told to
lift the rod if the bobber bobs at all.
Don't get me
wrong. I really don't care how anyone fishes, because fishing is fun. I
still figure the 5-year-old kid with a
cane pole, bobber and worm catching bluegills is a purist, and that everyone
else is a snob. I know that I am. And an opinionated snob at that.
It just seems sad
that folks are not learning to cast a fly rod, which is elegant and lovely,
but difficult to do with lead and a bobber attached to the leader.
I much prefer
watching a fly drift on the water rather than a hunk of poly yarn.
What do you
think?